Buying checklist: 0 of 0 items confirmed
Before You Meet the Agent
Gather these documents before the first conversation with an independent disability insurance broker
✓
Gather your income documentation Required
Carriers require proof of earned income to determine your maximum benefit. Have your most recent tax return (1040 with Schedule C if self-employed), two recent pay stubs, and your employment contract or partnership agreement ready.
✓
Review any existing coverage — employer group LTD and individual policies
Pull the full policy documents for any group LTD through your employer and any individual policies you already hold. Note the benefit amount, definition of disability, elimination period, and benefit period. You need this to identify your coverage gaps before buying.
✓
If in residency or fellowship — check whether your program offers a GSI plan Key for women
What is a GSI disability insurance plan? A Guaranteed Standard Issue (GSI) program allows resident physicians to purchase own-occupation disability coverage without individual medical underwriting, typically at unisex pricing 40–50% lower than individually underwritten gender-specific rates. The GSI window closes permanently when residency or fellowship ends.
Contact your GME or residency coordinator before approaching any individual carrier. GSI (Guaranteed Standard Issue) programs offer no-medical-underwriting coverage and, critically, unisex pricing for female residents — typically 40–50% lower than individually purchased gender-specific rates, and in some cases more depending on carrier and specialty. This window closes permanently when training ends.
✓
Choose an independent broker — not a captive agent of one carrier
An independent broker can show you policies from all Big 5 carriers (Guardian, MassMutual, Principal, The Standard, Ameritas) side by side. A captive agent represents only one carrier. The policy structure across carriers differs meaningfully — you need comparison access.
✓
Calculate your target monthly benefit
Your benefit should cover essential monthly expenses — housing, debt service, basic living costs — not your full income. A common target is 60–70% of gross monthly income. Note that benefits from individually-purchased policies paid with after-tax premiums are generally received income-tax-free, which increases their effective value.
During the Agent Meeting
Ask these five questions verbatim before signing any physician disability policy — request written confirmation for each answer
Q1
On the Definition Clause
"Does this policy use a True Own-Occupation definition — and can you show me the exact definition clause in writing before I sign?"
Why it matters: Agents routinely describe Modified Own-Occ and Transitional Own-Occ policies as "own-occupation coverage." Under a True Own-Occupation definition, you collect full benefits even while earning income in another role. Modified Own-Occ converts to any-occupation after 24 months. The words are technically accurate — but they hide what matters most at claim time. Asking for the clause in writing shifts the conversation from what the agent says to what the contract actually says. If the agent hesitates, treat that as a signal.
Q2
On the Residual Rider
"Does the residual benefit rider require a prior period of total disability before it activates — and can you confirm that in writing from the carrier?"
Why it matters: The residual or partial disability rider pays a proportional benefit — a 50% income loss triggers a 50% monthly benefit — even while you continue working. The total disability prerequisite clause quietly strips most of the residual rider's value for partial and gradual disabilities, which represent the majority of physician claims. An agent's verbal confirmation means nothing. The written carrier language governs at claim time. Nothing else does.
Q3
On the Future Increase Option Rider
"At what age does the Future Increase Option rider expire, what are the exercise windows, and what is the maximum benefit I can accumulate over time?"
Why it matters: The FIO rider protects your insurability — that is accurate. What agents often leave out is the expiry age (typically 45 or 50) and the defined windows you must actively use. A physician who buys coverage at 29 and never exercises the FIO windows may find the rider has lapsed by the time they actually need it. Get the full schedule in writing.
Q4
On the COLA Rider
"Is the COLA rider calculated on a simple or compound basis — and can you provide a written illustration showing the 10-year and 20-year benefit projections under both structures?"
Why it matters: Simple and compound COLA riders both advertise the same 3% rate. Over a 20-year claim on a $10,000/month base, the compound structure pays out more than $140,000 in additional cumulative benefit vs. simple interest. A written projection puts a concrete number on record. Ask this at renewal too — some carriers offer a COLA upgrade then, and most physicians never know to ask.
Q5
On Portability
"If I leave my current employer or change practice settings, does this policy remain in force under exactly the same terms — and does my premium or definition of disability change in any way?"
Why it matters: Group LTD policies tied to hospital employment are not portable — and as noted above, they are typically ERISA-governed, which further limits your legal rights in a dispute. Leave the employer, lose the coverage. An individual policy is yours and travels with you regardless of where you practice. If the answer is anything other than a clear yes, ask for the portability clause in writing.
After the meeting
Request the full policy illustration, specimen contract, and written answers to all five questions above via email. Do not sign anything until you have reviewed the actual contract language — not the summary brochure.
Before You Sign — Contract Verification
What should physicians verify before signing a disability insurance policy? Before signing, physicians must confirm: (1) True Own-Occ definition naming their specialty, (2) Non-Cancelable AND Guaranteed Renewable (NCGR) terms, (3) benefit period to age 65 or 67, (4) FIO rider attached with exercise windows noted, (5) compound COLA confirmed in writing, (6) residual rider without total disability prerequisite, (7) ERISA status of any group LTD, and (8) 90-day liquid reserve of $66,000 minimum ($88,000 practical target).
Confirm each item in the actual policy document, not the summary sheet
✓
Definition clause is True Own-Occupation Required
The language must name your medical specialty — not just "your occupation." Look for phrases like "unable to perform the material duties of your specialty" and confirm it pays even while working in another capacity.
✓
Policy is Non-Cancelable AND Guaranteed Renewable Required
Both terms must appear. Non-cancelable means the carrier cannot raise your premiums. Guaranteed renewable means they cannot cancel your coverage. You need both — not one or the other.
✓
Benefit period runs to age 65 or 67 Required
Policies with 2-year or 5-year benefit periods cost less but leave a career-ending disability at age 40 unprotected for 25+ years. Confirm the benefit period in writing — it determines the ceiling of your protection, not just the floor.
✓
Future Increase Option (FIO) rider is attached Required
Verify the exercise windows, the expiry age, and the maximum benefit ceiling. Put the expiry date in your calendar immediately. Missing an FIO window permanently forfeits your right to increase coverage without medical underwriting.
✓
COLA rider is confirmed compound — not simple Required
Ask the carrier to illustrate 10-year and 20-year benefit values under both structures in writing. Over a 20-year claim, the compound version pays out more than $140,000 extra on a $10,000/month base.
✓
Residual benefit rider does NOT require prior total disability Critical
Get this confirmed in writing from the carrier — not the agent. This clause alone determines whether a partial disability claim pays or is denied. Gradual and partial disabilities represent the majority of physician claims.
✓
Elimination period confirmed and liquid reserve verified
Calculate 90 days of expenses at your current spending level. Confirm that reserve sits in liquid savings — not in a 401(k) or IRA — before the policy takes effect. A physician earning $400,000/year spending $22,000/month needs $66,000 in liquid reserves before the 90-day standard elimination period expires.
✓
Occupation class is locked at purchase — not re-evaluated at claim Critical
Confirm the policy locks your occupation class at the time of purchase. Some policies can reclassify your occupation if you change specialties or practice settings, which may alter your definition of disability at claim time.
✓
If female — GSI availability confirmed through your programme Key for women
This is the only window for unisex pricing in most carrier structures. Once it closes at the end of residency, it does not reopen. Contact your residency coordinator today. Waiting until attending years means paying 40–50% more — and sometimes significantly more — for identical coverage permanently. On a $5,000/month benefit, the 30-year lifetime cost difference is approximately $40,320.
✓
Confirm whether your group LTD plan is governed by ERISA Critical
Most employer-sponsored group long-term disability (LTD) plans are governed by ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 1001) — a federal law that fundamentally restructures your legal rights if a claim is denied. Under ERISA: no jury trial, no state-law consumer protections, no punitive damages, and the court reviews only the administrative record the insurer used to deny you. An individual policy falls outside ERISA and retains full state-law protections — including the right to a jury trial and bad-faith damages. A critical additional point: most group LTD plans grant administrators discretionary authority, which means courts apply an "arbitrary and capricious" standard — the insurer's denial stands unless plainly unreasonable. Confirm in writing whether your group plan is ERISA-governed.
✓
Do NOT rely solely on employer group LTD Avoid
Group plans are almost always Modified Own-Occ — converting to any-occupation after 24 months — and they are not portable. Benefits from employer-paid group LTD are also typically taxable income. They can supplement an individual policy, but they cannot replace one.
✓ Buying Checklist Complete
You have confirmed all contract items. Your policy foundation is solid — save or print this checklist for your records.
Renewal checklist: 0 of 0 items reviewed
When to review your policy
When should physicians review their disability insurance? Review your own-occupation disability coverage annually, and specifically after any of the following: income increase of 20%+, change of employer or practice setting, marriage or new dependents, completion of fellowship or subspecialty training, new health conditions, or reaching age 40.
Review Your Current Coverage
Confirm your existing policy still matches your actual financial exposure
✓
Confirm your current monthly benefit relative to your current income
Divide your current monthly benefit by your current gross monthly income. If the percentage has fallen below 50–60%, your coverage has drifted materially. A resident policy that was never upgraded through an FIO rider may cover less than 10% of an attending income. Calculate the gap today.
✓
Check whether any FIO option windows are open or approaching
Locate your FIO schedule in the original policy. If an option window is open or within the next 12 months, act before it lapses. The Future Increase Option (FIO) rider — also called Future Purchase Option (FPO) at some carriers — lets you increase your monthly disability benefit at set intervals without new medical underwriting. FIO increases require income documentation but no medical underwriting — the easiest way to raise your benefit without a health review.
✓
Confirm the FIO rider has not expired
Most FIO riders expire at age 45 or 50. If you are approaching or past that age, this is your final opportunity to increase coverage without full medical underwriting. Contact your carrier or broker immediately to confirm the expiry date and your remaining options.
✓
Verify the definition of disability has not changed
A non-cancelable policy guarantees the carrier cannot change the definition. A guaranteed-renewable-only policy may allow definition changes for an entire rate class. Confirm the exact definition clause in your current policy document — not the original summary sheet you signed years ago.
✓
Check whether your COLA rider offers an upgrade at renewal
Some carriers offer a COLA upgrade from simple to compound interest at defined renewal intervals — on a $10,000/month base, that difference exceeds $140,000 in cumulative benefit over 20 years. Ask your broker whether this option exists on your policy.
Coverage Gap Analysis
Identify what your current policy does not cover
✓
Calculate your current income-to-benefit gap
Target benefit = monthly essential expenses × 1.1 (to account for inflation buffer). If your current benefit falls below this, you have a quantifiable gap. Document it: gap = target benefit − current benefit. This is the number to bring to your broker.
✓
Review whether your employment status change has created a portability risk
If you have changed employers since your last review, confirm your individual policy remains fully portable under the current carrier terms. If you have added group LTD through a new employer, confirm whether it offsets your individual benefit and whether it will terminate if you leave.
✓
Confirm your 90-day emergency reserve is still in place
If your income has grown since you last set your emergency fund, recalculate: 90 days × current monthly spending. This figure must sit in liquid savings outside retirement accounts. Update the reserve as your income increases.
✓
Assess whether new health conditions require re-evaluation of total coverage strategy
Any change in health status that would affect insurability makes your existing policy more valuable and new underwriting more difficult. If new conditions have emerged, protect what you have. Consult a broker before making any changes that might require new medical underwriting.
Action Items
What to do based on what you found
✓
If a coverage gap exists — contact your broker to explore supplemental coverage options
Supplemental individual policies can close the gap between your current benefit and your income exposure. Bring your income documentation and your existing policy to the conversation. Do not allow new coverage to be issued before reviewing whether it will offset existing benefits.
✓
Exercise any open FIO windows before expiry
If a window is open, complete the increase. You will need proof of current earned income. The premium increases at your current age — not your original issue age — but the underlying contract terms, including the definition of disability, remain unchanged.
✓
Document this review and schedule the next one
Record the date of this review, your current benefit amount, your current income, and any actions taken. Set a calendar reminder for 12 months. Your disability policy needs reviewing, not filing. Treat it as an active part of your financial plan.
✓ Renewal Review Complete
You have reviewed all key areas of your existing coverage. Document your findings and share them with your broker or financial advisor.
Next: Income Architecture
You've Physician Income Architecture — Next Steps After Securing Disability Coverage
Buying a sound disability policy protects your income if things go wrong. Most physicians stop there. The 10% Upgrade Rule is a framework for attending physicians who want to build wealth, buy a home, and grow their lifestyle — without underfunding retirement or building a budget that buckles under pressure.
Disclaimer: This checklist is for educational purposes only and does not constitute insurance, financial, tax, or legal advice. Policy features, definitions, and carrier practices vary by state, carrier, and individual circumstance. Before purchasing or modifying any disability insurance policy, consult a licensed independent insurance broker, a qualified fee-only financial advisor, and if appropriate, a licensed attorney. Policy contract language governs all claim determinations.